Customer Reviews

Willingness to research for best options.

Great team, works hard to find insurance that fits the needs of customers.

Penny is a delight to work with! She made transferring our policies to our new home in Staunton so easy—and saved us money, too! We feel very secure knowing we’re covered with Erie and can depend on Penny to look out for us.

Great rates and friendly service

It’s nice to work with someone you can actually build a relationship with. Fred has been very good to my family, and I have sent many of my own customers to him because I know they will be taken care of.

I love Katie she is so amazing.!

The team of agents at Staley Insurance are just always quick to answer any questions we have and we like that they send checking in notes.

Staley has always stood by my needs, for years. I feel protected…

Staley Insurance has been such a wonderful experience from start to finish! Paula was so kind and welcoming — she made everything feel easy and comfortable right away. Katie was absolutely incredible to work with. She was patient, knowledgeable, and went above and beyond to make sure I understood all of my options. Most importantly, she saved me hundreds compared to my old insurance policy! I am beyond happy and so grateful for their help. If you’re looking for an insurance team that truly cares and works hard for you, I highly recommend Staley Insurance!

Fred was great to deal with!